So held the Appellate Division, Second Department, in its July 2, 2014 decision in Bustamante v. Donawa, upholding the order of Kings County Family Court Judge Michael L. Katz. That order, in turn, denied the father’s objections to an order of Support Magistrate Nicholas Palos that imputed income to the father when granting a mother’s petition for an upward modification of the father’s child support obligation.
The Support Magistrate based the increase in the father’s support obligation from that contained in a 2008 order on the father’s 2011 annual income of $54,342.00. That was earned by the father from a former occupation as a Traffic Device Maintainer. The father argued that the Magistrate should have used his current annual income of $31,756.40, as reflected in his most recent pay stub arising out of his current occupation as an Emergency Medical Technician.
The Second Department held the father’s contention was without merit. The Court noted that a Support Magistrate may impute income based on the party’s past income or demonstrated earning potential. The Magistrate is afforded considerable discretion and that determination may properly be based upon a parent’s prior employment experience.
Here, the Court held it was appropriate to impute the higher past income to the father where he had voluntarily left his employment.
While a parent is entitled to attempt to improve his vocation, his children should not be expected to subsidize his decision.
Here, there was no discussion of how the mother met the changed circumstances threshold needed to obtain an upward modification of support. Neither was there any suggestion that the father was motivated by anything other than a desire to get ahead.
However, the decision invites the question whether the father will be entitled to some credit or leeway if and when his attempt to better himself pans out. If and when the father’s income exceeds what he would have earned as a Traffic Device Maintainer, will the mother be entitled to still another increase?
Both parties represented themselves.